10 Best Paella Pans 2022 - Carbon & Stainless Steel Paella Pan The Best Paella Pan Reviews 2022 1. Lodge Carbon Steel Paella Pan - 8/10/12/15 inch OUR TOP PICK If you swear by local brands, this one is made in the US. It comes pre-seasoned so you can use it immediately. The cast iron holds and spreads heat well. Check Price On Amazon 15-inch pans are the most common kind for home cooking.